By Freddie Jennings
PIERRE Sage was dismissed as Crystal Palace manager after just ten Premier League games in charge. A run of four straight league defeats by an aggregate scoreline of 12-1 proved the Frenchman’s undoing. A win away to Fulham in the Carabao Cup wasn’t enough for him to save his job.
One of the main reasons for Palace’s struggles was the regular concession of poor goals from set-pieces and counter-attacks, which Sage ought to take a lot of the blame for. However, was it really his fault that Palace couldn’t mark the back post properly from corners? Was it his fault that the defence’s lack of pace was routinely exposed on the counter-attack? The answer perhaps is no.
The drop-off in form of key players also set the manager back, with Adam Wharton and Chris Richards both not being at the same level as in recent seasons.
Absentees also played a part in the Eagles’ struggles with Jean-Philippe Mateta and Ismaila Sarr, Palace’s two top-scorers last season, both being sidelined through injury and the former recently through suspension.
Defender Chadi Riad sustained a season-ending injury on the opening day away to Everton and if he had replicated his form towards the end of last season it would have been invaluable for a current team that is struggling.
However, one of the other main reasons for Palace’s struggles has been boardroom incompetence. The sales of Marc Guehi and Maxence Lacroix this year have naturally left a big void in Palace’s defensive set-up. A void that the board were unable to fill during the summer. In fact, the unnecessary sale of Daniel Munoz also left the team without a key member of the FA Cup and Conference League-winning side. His replacement Anan Khalaili has been unable to replicate the Colombian’s importance and the team is clearly lacking in leadership.
All three of the above acted as big personalities for this Palace team and players who provided organisation and stability. The board have failed in replacing them. A defensive trio of Honest Ahanor, Axel Disasi and Takehiro Tomiyasu arrived but have been unable to earn their places in the team, whether that is because of injury or inexperience. While other summer signings Dwight McNeil and Dario Osorio have bolstered attacking options, they weren’t able to produce a big enough impact for Sage.
Sporting director Matt Hobbs was appointed in October of last year. He replaced the much-loved Dougie Freedman who was responsible for the signings of the likes of Guehi, Wharton and Michael Olise for relatively small fees from the Championship. Since Hobbs arrived the two major signings have been Jorgen Strand Larsen for £50 million and Brennan Johnson for £35 million. Both fees now look too high and the latter has already departed for Everton.
It has been reported that last month a meeting was held with Hobbs when he was put under scrutiny regarding the recent string of underwhelming signings. It is clear that certain mistakes above him made Sage’s job tougher than it needed to be. Replacing the beloved Oliver Glasner was always going to be a tall order, but Sage wasn’t given the same tools that the Austrian had during his two-and-a-half years in SE25.
Similarly, Sage wasn’t afforded as much time or patience from the board that Glasner was. At the start of the 2024-25 campaign, Palace had the same number of points after ten games as they do currently. Glasner’s team went on to finish with the club’s highest-ever Premier League points tally and win the FA Cup at Wembley against Manchester City. Yet Sage was not given the opportunity to rectify mistakes made in the opening ten league matches and it appears he was given less ammunition than his predecessor.
Reports have claimed that Thomas Frank is close to being appointed. The Dane will have to solidify the defence in a way that Sage could not, but it remains to be seen whether the ex-Brentford and Tottenham Hotspur manager will be given the resources required to improve Palace’s fortunes with a big January window incoming.
What is not in doubt is that Frank needs to be given a better chance to thrive than Sage was.





